Difference between Top-down, Bottom up and Interactive Reading Approach.
Bottom-Up Models
|
Top-Down Models
|
Interactive Models
|
1960s - 1970s
|
1970s - 1980s
|
late 1980s - present
|
- Reading is a decoding process (focus
on the text).
- The phonics approach to
teaching reading is used.
|
Reading is a psycholinguistic guessing
game (focus on the reader).
- The "whole language"
approach to teaching reading is used.
|
Reading is a process of constructing
meaning from text through the use of both bottom-up and
top-down processes, strategies, and skills (focus on the interaction).
- The balanced approach to
teaching reading is used.
|
1) alphabet letters + sounds g words
2)
words + grammar rules
g sentences
3) sentences + discourse rules g paragraphs g longer
discourses
|
1) The reader receives input from the text, makes predictions (based
on conceptual abilities, background knowledge, and language processing
skills), tests and confirms or revises those
prediction.
2) Use a holistic approach
to reading and writing that advocates the use of children's literature and
authentic reading materials.
|
1) Both bottom-up and top-down processes occur simultaneously for
the reader to comprehend the meaning of the text.
2) Two levels of interaction:
- the interaction between the
reader and the text.
- the interaction between two
kinds of cognitive skills: identification and interpretation.
|
Comments
Post a Comment